Skip to content

Simple Investing

Cash & Fixed Income

Where to Park Safe Cash: HYSA vs. Money Market Funds (SPAXX) vs. Treasury Bills vs. Bond ETFs

From Simple Investing · 14 articles · latest

Grouped bar chart comparing headline yield and after-tax yield across big-bank savings, HYSA, SPAXX, 3-month T-bills, and BND
Headline APY lies in high-tax states. State-tax-exempt Treasury bills regularly beat higher advertised money market and bank yields after tax.

If you still have $40,000 sitting in a Chase, Bank of America, or Wells Fargo savings account earning 0.01% to 0.05% APY, you are giving your bank an interest-free loan of roughly $1,700 a year. Worse, when people finally wake up and move that money, they either chase promotional online bank apps that slash rates six months later, or they dump their house down payment into an intermediate bond fund like BND and get blindsided when interest rates jump and their "safe cash" drops 10%.

In our Simple 3-Symbol Portfolio, 10% of the allocation sits in safe liquid reserves (SPAXX), and as we track every week in Market Updates, short-term Treasury yields above 4% have completely changed the math on cash. Here is how to evaluate every safe-cash vehicle without falling for headline APY illusions.

The Four Safe-Cash Contenders

Not all "cash" behaves the same way under stress or on your Form 1099-INT/DIV in April. Compare them across four dimensions: liquidity, principal stability, federal/state taxes, and fee drag.

VehicleTypical Yield RangeFederal TaxState & Local TaxPrincipal RiskBest Use Case
Big-Bank Savings0.01% – 0.05%OrdinaryTaxedNone (FDIC)Checking buffer only
Online HYSA3.75% – 4.25%OrdinaryTaxedNone (FDIC)Instant debit/ACH emergency cash
Money Market (SPAXX / VMFXX)4.20% – 4.50%OrdinaryMostly taxed*Near zero (NAV $1.00)Brokerage settlement & dry powder
3-Month T-Bills (SGOV / Direct)4.40% – 4.65%Ordinary100% ExemptUltra-low (duration ~0.12 yr)High-tax states, house down payments
Agg Bond ETF (BND)4.50% – 4.80%OrdinaryPartially exemptHigh (~6 yr duration)Long-term portfolio ballast, not cash

Note: VMFXX holds a large share of federal obligations (varying by year), whereas SPAXX holds significant repurchase agreements that are often non-exempt at the state level depending on your state's minimum-threshold rules.

The High-Tax State Secret: State Tax Exemption

Look closely at that chart above. Suppose you live in California (9.3% marginal state bracket), New York (6.85%+), Massachusetts, or New Jersey, and sit in the 24% federal bracket:

  • An Online HYSA paying 4.00% APY loses 24% to the IRS and 9.3% to Sacramento (assuming standard deduction or SALT cap), leaving roughly 2.67% after tax.
  • Fidelity SPAXX paying ~4.35%—because repurchase agreements typically do not qualify for state Treasury exemption in California, New York, or Connecticut—drops to roughly 2.90% after tax.
  • 3-Month U.S. Treasury Bills (bought directly via TreasuryDirect / Fidelity / Schwab, or via an ultra-short ETF like SGOV) paying 4.55% are 100% exempt from state and local income tax under federal statute (31 U.S.C. § 3124). After 24% federal tax, you keep 3.46%.

To match a 4.55% state-tax-exempt Treasury bill in California's 9.3% bracket, a taxable HYSA would need to pay over 5.18% APY. Most savers chase 15 basis points of promotional bank APY while quietly lighting 55+ basis points on fire in state taxes.

Tip

Use Treasury-Only Money Market Funds if You Want One-Click Simplicity: If you hate rolling T-bills or selling SGOV shares when you need cash, look at Treasury-only money market mutual funds like FDLXX (Fidelity) or VUSXX (Vanguard). Because their portfolios hold U.S. Treasuries rather than bank repos, the vast majority of their dividend income remains state-tax-exempt—though you still need to check the custodian's annual state-tax-exempt percentage PDF at tax time (especially in CA, NY, and CT, which require >50% of assets in federal obligations at every quarter-end).

The Duration Trap: Why BND Is Not Cash

I cannot stress this enough: do not park your house down payment or emergency fund in BND, AGG, or a 10-year Treasury ETF.

Intermediate aggregate bond funds carry an effective duration of roughly 6 years. Duration is simple math: for every 1.0% rise in prevailing interest rates, a fund with 6-year duration loses roughly 6% of its market value. We lived through that exact lesson in 2022, when BND fell roughly 13% right alongside stocks while inflation surged and the Fed hiked.

If you need money in 6 to 24 months, duration is uncompensated risk. Stick to instruments with duration under 90 days:

  1. Individual 4-week, 8-week, or 13-week T-bills bought at auction on Fidelity, Schwab, or Vanguard with zero commission and auto-roll enabled.
  2. Ultra-short Treasury ETFs (SGOV or USFR) with 0.07%–0.15% expense ratios and T+1 liquidity.
  3. FDIC-insured HYSA for the immediate 1–2 months of checking overflow where same-day ACH speed matters more than a half-percent of yield.

How to Read SEC 7-Day Yield vs. APY

Brokerage money market funds quote a 7-day SEC yield (which already has the fund's expense ratio subtracted), while banks quote APY (annual percentage yield including monthly compounding). Note that Fidelity's default SPAXX carries a 0.42% internal expense ratio—already netted out of the quoted 7-day yield—while SGOV charges 0.09% and raw T-bills bought at auction charge 0.00%.

Check FINRA's Investor Insights on Treasury securities if you are placing your first T-bill order, and verify how your brokerage handles auto-reinvestment so your cash never sits uninvested after maturity. Keep checking your cash against Rung 2 of The Financial Waterfall: safe cash exists to buy stability and optionality, not to squeeze out the last nickel of risk.

Keep reading

Comments