Staying the Course: Rebalancing, Sequence of Returns Risk, and Avoiding Behavioral Traps
From Simple Investing · 14 articles · latest
Anyone can look like a disciplined long-term index investor when the S&P 500 is climbing 20% a year and every dip recovers by Tuesday. Real investing discipline only gets tested when headlines scream about post-election macro friction, Treasury yield spikes, or corporate turbulence and your brokerage screen drops $80,000 in six weeks.
Almost every bad investing outcome I have seen from smart people was not caused by picking the wrong index fund. It was caused by behavioral capitulation—converting a temporary paper drawdown into permanent capital destruction—or by entering retirement with zero plan for Sequence of Returns Risk (SORR).
If The Investing Foundation is your engine, rebalancing and SORR defense are your brakes and suspension.
The Math of Sequence of Returns Risk
During your working years, the order of market returns barely matters as long as you keep contributing. In fact, a sharp bear market in year three of a 30-year career is a gift: your monthly paycheck buys discounted shares.
The moment you stop earning a paycheck and start withdrawing living expenses, that math flips violently. Consider two retirees, both starting with $1,000,000 and withdrawing $40,000/year (adjusted for inflation), both averaging the exact same 7.0% annualized return over 20 years:
- Retiree A hits a +20%, +15%, +12% bull run in Years 1–3 before suffering a -30% bear market in Year 10. Their portfolio compounds ahead of withdrawals and finishes with well over $1.8 million.
- Retiree B gets hit with -25% and -15% in Years 1 and 2 right after quitting their job. Even though Years 4–20 boom, they had to sell shares at depressed trough prices to buy groceries—permanently starving the recovery base. They risk running out of money by Year 18.
That asymmetry—where early drawdowns hurt far more than late drawdowns—is Sequence of Returns Risk. You do not beat it by guessing when the next recession starts. You beat it structurally with a liquid cash/short-bond buffer (like the 10% SPAXX or Treasury bill slice in The 3-Symbol Portfolio) plus a mechanical rebalancing rule.
Calendar vs. Threshold Rebalancing (The 5/25 Rule)
Rebalancing is simply the unemotional discipline of trimming whatever got expensive and buying whatever got cheap. Notice what happens when equities drop 30%: your 60% VOO / 30% VXUS / 10% SPAXX portfolio drifts toward ~51% / 26% / 23% cash. Rebalancing forces you to spend that excess SPAXX cash to buy discounted equities at the exact moment your instincts tell you to freeze.
Ignore the financial advisor myth that you need to rebalance every month. Quarterly or monthly rebalancing adds churn without improving returns. Instead, pick one of two clean rules:
- Annual Calendar Rebalance: Pick one boring date a year (your birthday, or November 15 after dividends settle) and reset weights back to target.
- The 5/25 Threshold Rule (Larry Swedroe's Band): Only rebalance when an asset class drifts by 5 percentage points absolute (e.g., 60% US stocks hits 65% or 55%) OR 25% relative to its target weight (e.g., a 10% cash bucket rises to 12.5% or drops to 7.5%). Check once a quarter; act only when a band breaks.
Warning
Rebalance With Cash Flow First in Taxable Accounts: Never sell appreciated shares in a taxable brokerage account to rebalance if you can avoid it. Turn off automatic dividend reinvestment (DRIP) in your taxable account, route dividends to your settlement fund, and direct all new contributions + dividends toward whichever slice is underweight. Save explicit buy/sell trades for tax-advantaged accounts (401(k) and Roth IRA) where trades trigger zero capital gains taxes.
Three Behavioral Traps That Wreck Good Portfolios
Even with a clean asset allocation and optimal asset location, three predictable psychological traps derail investors during volatile quarters:
- Trap 1: Checking Balances Daily During Drawdowns. Looking at your portfolio every morning increases your odds of panic-selling without giving you any actionable information. According to research summarized by Vanguard's Behavioral Coaching framework, staying disciplined through volatility is one of the largest drivers of advisor/process alpha—worth more than fund picking or tax tweaks combined.
- Trap 2: Confusing News Volatility With Permanent Loss. Election years, Fed rate pivots, and headline corporate scandals—the exact noise we unpack in Market Updates—trigger sharp 5% to 15% equity swings. Historically, the S&P 500 experiences an intra-year drawdown of ~14% in an average calendar year, yet finishes positive roughly three out of four years.
- Trap 3: Moving to Cash "Until Things Settle Down." Nobody rings a bell at the market bottom. When things "feel safe" again in the news, equities have almost always already rallied 20% to 35% off the lows. Missing just the 10 best recovery days over a 20-year window—which routinely cluster within days of the worst crash days—cuts total compounded returns roughly in half.
Your One-Page Bear Market Protocol
Write down your rule before the next 20% drop hits, and keep it in your investment notes:
- Confirm your 12–24 months of living expenses (or 3–6 months emergency fund if still working) sit safely in
SPAXX/ T-bills—so you never need to sell stocks into a storm. - When an equity band breaches your 5/25 threshold, execute the buy order inside your IRA/401(k) without reading financial television commentary first.
- Harvest taxable losses opportunistically (swapping e.g.
VOO→IVVorVTI→SCHB, avoiding 30-day IRS wash-sale violations) to bank capital loss carryforwards while staying 100% invested in the market.
Volatility is not a defect in equities—it is the admission fee for earning 9%–10% long-run nominal returns instead of 4% Treasury yields. Pay the fee calmly, rebalance by the numbers, and let time do the rest.
Comments